Dec 20, 2010
-JSA, James Spence Authentication, recently authenticated a telegram sent by Harry Wright to player Bob Allen in 1891. JSA said it bore an authentic signature of Phillies manager Harry Wright. But the handwriting doesn’t even remotely match Wright’s, and the telegram was clearly documented as the one player Bob Allen was delivered on the receiving end. It was written by a telegraph operator in Cleveland and put in an envelope (which also was presented to JSA with the telegram) for delivery to Allen. How can collectors be confident JSA can authenticate Mickey Mantle and Cal Ripken signatures, when they drop the ball on an item like this?
-The Harry Wright telegram controversy made its way onto Net54, where a collector with the handle Old13man described a communication he had with Robert Edward Auctions head Rob Lifson and posed the question: “..we are baffled as to can a telegram be written by Wright? Would he call the telegram or could he have written one to then be sent?”
Answer: Yes, telegrams written by Harry Wright do exist and they are the actual original copies he walked into or delivered to the telegraph offices on his end in the transmission. Examples of these handwritten Wright telegrams are found in the New York Public Library’s Vol. 2 scrapbook of the Harry Wright Correspondence Collection. Of course, volumes 1, 3 and 4 were stolen from the NYPL in the 1970s along with many other telegram drafts that Wright executed in his own hand. If collectors have any similar Harry Wright telegrams in their collection, they should contact the New York office of the FBI at: firstname.lastname@example.org .
-Harry Wright’s stolen telegrams have appeared on the market in the past few decades. One was sold in Mastro’s April, 1999, sale as part of a “Humongous Hall of Fame Autograph Collection.”
-The Baseball Hall of Fame’s letters addressed to August Herrmann appear to have surfaced in other sales conducted by Mike Gutierrez. In May of 2003 he sold a lot of over 100 letters in his MGA auction, including at least one letter to Herrmann from John Ganzel. In October of 2004, he again sold the Ganzel letter to Herrmann dated Feb. 9, 1910. In the letter Ganzel writes Herrmann, on behalf of the Rochester “Hustlers” Baseball Club, asking for a leave of absence for player William Maloney. At the National Baseball Libraryin Cooperstown, the Herrmann Papers archive features two folders of letters from Ganzel to Herrmann. One of those letters is dated Feb. 12, 1910, and Ganzel tells Herrmann, “Your very kind…favor of Feb. 10th, in reply to mine of the 9th, relative to player Maloney, duly received.”
-Babe Ruth forgeries are everywhere…..Sports Collectors Daily just advertised an embarassingly fake Ruth signature on a “2010 Topps Tribute” card, and alleges it features authentic signatures of the 1927 Yankees. Here’s the article: http://www.sportscollectorsdaily.com/1927-yankees-topps-tribute-card-pulled-consigned/ Billed as a “1-1 Legendary Lineups autograph book card,” the Topps product features horrible forgeries of both Ruth and Gehrig. Who authenticated this one? The experts we spoke to deemed them poorly executed forgeries. The card is being offered on EBAY by Beckett Select Auctions with a minimum bid of $20,000.
-A comment by Richard Simon on Net54 sums up the cut signature fiasco best. He said: “If Upper Deck can be stupid enough to use multiple forgeries in their cards, why can’t Topps be stupid too?”
-In the New Year, Hauls of Shame will also examine the many Babe Ruth forgeries sold in Sotheby’s Halper Collection Auction.
-Speaking of the “Sultan of Swat”, Dave Grob, is thoroughly researching Ruth’s alleged 1914 Red Sox “rookie jersey” that was once one of the premier items in the Barry Halper Collection. We hear he’s uncovered even more evidence that proves this Bambino is “cursed.”
-We hear that collectors should keep their eyes peeled for a large group of Tomlinson Detroit player cabinets that were stolen from the NYPL’s Spalding Collection. We will examine this story closer in the near future.
- Hauls of Shame will usher in 2011 with the unveiling of an exclusive report featuring the “Halper HOT 100 List.” The list features the top 100 stolen items that were once part of the Barry Halper Collection.
UPDATE (Dec. 27, 2010): Although the Beckett Select Ebay auction was terminated early for the 1927 Yankee “Topps Tribute Card,” neither Topps nor Beckett returned phone calls inquiring who authenticated the Ruth and Gehrig signatures. The video featuring the card, once featured on the Beckett site, is also inaccessible.
-Although it has been definitively established that the 1891 Harry Wright telegram to Bob Allen was written by a telegraph operator, and not Harry Wright, the telegram, (still with its LOA from James Spence Authentication) is being peddled as a real Wright signature in Steve Verkman’s current Clean Sweep Auction. http://www.csauctions.com/item.cgi?show_item=0000310685
UPDATE (Dec. 29, 2010): Beckett disclosed that the 1927 Yankee “Topps Tribute” card was pulled from the EBAY auction because of the questions about the authenticity of the signatures featured on the card. They also confirmed that PSA/DNA authenticated the item and that they still stand behind their opinion that all of the signatures are genuine. Beckett is reported to be consulting with James Spence Authentication (JSA) for an additional opinion on the item. That’s the same James Spence who authenticated a telegram written by a telegraph operator, as an authentic Harry Wright signature- That’s the same telegram still being offered for sale with a fraudulent JSA LOA at Clean Sweep Auctions.
(Special thanks go to those contributing to our reporting via our “Tips” line at: Tips@haulsofshame.com)