April 29, 2011
|One of Lou Gehrig’s 1938 jerseys for sale at REA|
When it started its journey back in 1938, baseball fans could hardly have imagined that a grey flannel made for Lou Gehrig would some day sell at auction in excess of $200,000. Since 1938, that same garment has likely passed through the hands of Gehrig, Yankee clubhouse men, at least four auction houses and a handful of wealthy collectors.
Robert Edward Auctions is selling that Gehrig 1938 Yankee road jersey in their Spring 2011 auction and the offering has stirred up some controversy in the high-end uniform world. Last month, REA president, Rob Lifson, claimed to have a photo match of Gehrig in the exact same jersey during the 1938 World Series, but REA’s authenticator of the jersey, Dave Grob, of MEARS, disputed Lifson’s claim and explained why in a column first published on the MEARS website. Grob claimed that Lifson and REA were inflating and exaggerating the merits of what was already determined to have been an authentic garment likely to have been worn by the “Iron Horse.”
There was no photo match and Gehrig never wore the offered jersey in the 1938 World Series, as REA claimed. REA had also claimed that the jersey could have been the last one ever worn by Gehrig in a World Series during games three and four at Chicago. However, games three and four of the 1938 World Series were played at Yankee Stadium and Gehrig would have worn pinstripes in his last Series games.
Said Grob, “REA’s comments about being able to make a definitive claim based off imagery analysis are severely inflated and without merit.”
Lifson and REA responded to Grob on their blog and blamed their errors and exaggerations on the authenticator, MEARS, stating, “We went out of our way to specifically ask Troy Kinunen, the signer of the MEARS letter, if the description was clear in his opinion as to the distinction of what the MEARS letter was saying and what REA was saying. He responded in the affirmative.”
Grob wrote a follow-up article describing the ins-and-outs of imagery analysis and the pitfalls of claiming “photo matches,” while REA followed up with their own claim of yet another new ”photo match” alleging that Gehrig is wearing the same jersey in spring training.
Now that the arguments about the Gehrig flannel have been laid to rest, judgement on this jersey lies in the hands of the collectors willing to pay for it.
In consideration of the attempts made to authenticate and ”photo match” this garment, we thought we’d also point out the past history and provenance of the jersey, including some information the auction house doesn’t reference in their lot description.
LOU GEHRIG 1938 YANKEE ROAD JERSEY TIMELINE
1938- The Gehrig jersey’s journey begins when its delivered to the Yankees sometime before or during the 1938 American League campaign. REA claimed that Lou Gehrig was wearing this jersey in the World Series during October, but authenticator Dave Grob, refuted this claim stating Gehrig could have worn this jersey and others sometime during the 1938 season. REA claimed the number “4″ on the back of the jersey was distinctive to 1938, but Grob showed that the font of the Yankee number “4″ during those years was found on jerseys from several years of play. Grob believes all he can truthfully say is that the jersey is authentic and that Gehrig likely wore the jersey sometime during the 1938 season. Hauls of Shame found photos of Gehrig wearing three different road jerseys during 1938 and one of them, from April of 1938, appears as if it could be the jersey being offered at REA.
1991- Without any mention of where it had been since 1938, the Gehrig road jersey was offered for sale at San Francisco’s Richard Wolfers Auction House as part of their September ”Treasures of the Game” auction. The auction house noted the jersey was consigned by Sports Heroes Inc. On Sept. 6, 1991 The Los Angeles Times reports that the jersey sold for $220,000 to Mark Friedland of Aspen, Colo. A spokesman for Wolfers told the Times, “the final price made the jersey…the most expensive non-card sports memorabilia item ever sold.” Friedland told the Chicago Tribune that the jersey was “a cultural icon.”
At the time it sold in 1991, reports indicated the $220,000 sale price of the 1938 Gehrig jersey represented a “World Record.”
1994- The 1938 Gehrig jersey was featured in a New York Daily News special report on fraud in the memorabilia industry written by Bill Madden. The 1938 Gehrig jersey was pictured in the article along with forgeries and questioned items sold by Richard Wolfers Auctions and Sports Heroes Inc. In the report, Madden also recounts the history of what he calls a “1937 road uniform” of Gehrig and its owners, including, Andy Imperato, of Grey Flannel, Barry Halper and New Jersey opthalmologist Richard Angrist.
Madden reported that the jersey was consigned to an Oct. 17, 1993, Christies auction and that it failed to sell due to doubts about its authenticity. However, Christies never sold a Gehrig jersey at their baseball sale, which actually occurred on Oct. 2, 1993. Madden was possibly referring to the September, 1991, sale at Richard Wolfers, which featured the jersey pictured in his special report. But Madden could also have been referring to another Gehrig road jersey (an alleged ”1937-39″ example) that was offered at a Wolfers auction on June 2, 1993. The Wolfers catalogue description from 1991 stated that the Gehrig jersey was “made available through Sports Heroes Inc.”
Displayed next to the 1938 Gehrig jersey in the Daily News report was an alleged 1941 Hank Greenberg jersey, also from the Wolfers 1991 auction. Madden reported, “A 1941 Hank Greenberg Detroit Tigers home uniform, which knowledgeable collectors have said is a fake, was once sold at auction by Wolfers for $85,000.”
Madden’s report from May of 1994 implicated Wolfers Auctions’ principal Duane Garrett for selling bogus uniforms and autographed baseball gloves. On July 26, 1995, Garrett committed suicide by jumping off the Golden Gate Bridge in San Francisco.
1999- The 1938 Gehrig jersey was offered for sale in Chicago by Mastro Fine Sports Auctions. The auction house noted a tear on the jerseys shoulder and mentioned that ”The buttons have been replaced.” New York dealer John Brigandi wins the jersey for a price of $60,486, a far cry from its sale price of $220.000 in 1991. Collectors we interviewed believe the jersey’s ties to Duane Garrett, Wolfers Auctions and Sports Heroes Inc. contributed to the jersey’s poor showing at auction.
2008- Mastro Auctions offered the 1938 Gehrig road jersey again as lot 1044 in their August sale. They noted, “the jersey has undergone professional reinforcement within the shoulders.” The description also states that there were no “remnants or stitching from a (Worlds Fair) patch.” The jersey was graded “A-9″ by MEARS. The jersey sold for $240,000.
2011- The purchaser of the Gehrig jersey in the 2008 Mastro auction consigns it to REA. The auction house is currently offering the 1938 Gehrig road jersey as lot 7 in their annual spring sale. The current bid on the jersey is $85,000. Bidding on the jersey will have to be brisk in order to reach the level of the 1991 and 2008 sales, which exceeded $200,000.
Bidding for the Gehrig jersey ends on May 7th.